Why I don’t watch American Idol…
Yes, my last post was about not watching TV and this one is too- get used to it!
I wanted to comment on the phenomenon that American Idol has become and why I just can’t get into the show. The few times I have watched this show, I see young hotties with very little real-world music experience trotting around on stage to the delight of the audience. These young people, some of them not even in their 20s, are singing songs usually from another era- and I hope I’m not the only one to realize this, but their renditions don’t reflect an understanding of the spirit of the music. Maybe these young people have OK voices, or maybe they just have “Star Quality”, but it isn’t enough!
The reason I am ranting a bit about this is because I have long taken issue with the American Idol requirement that contestants be under 26. The fellow with the grey hair was lying, I’m sure- but this requirement is pure ageism in a culture that reveres youth. By having this requirement, the show is almost guaranteeing that they will have contestants whom they can package, brand, mold and market to the US. But what about the people we miss out on hearing because they are too old to be on the show?
A wonderful case-in-point was recently made on the UK version of American Idol, Britain’s got Talent. In the UK there is no age requirement for the show, and a 47 year old woman managed to get on the show and sing for Simon Cowell (who is spot- on with his critiques most of the time). Susan Boyle blew the audience away with her rendition of I Dreamed a Dream from Le Mis. As she took the stage, there was obvious disdain for her even being there. Who was this frumpy old housewife? She proceeded to wow audiences with her singing and even Simon was humbled. What was the public response to this woman’s talent? Well, her video on Youtube has had over 19 million views, and she has been offered a record deal in the UK. But some think that we shouldn’t go to such lengths to recognize the talents of older folks. Here’s a direct copy of an article in Entertainment Weekly regarding Susan Boyle’s sudden fame:
Not to be a grump, but am I the only one who finds this a little over-the-top and, frankly, a little condescending? Plenty of big-voiced PYTs sing their hearts out every week on American Idol (not to mention onstage in Broadway shows) without getting this kind of reaction. But Susan, because of her looks, because of the fact that people were snickering at her before she opened her mouth, becomes a sensation simply by being able to carry a tune. She has a decent voice, sure. But let’s not get carried away.
The writer seems to suggest that we shouldn’t pay any notice to 47 year old women and instead should concentrate our attention on the PYTs that American Idol trots out each week. That to me is like saying, “You don’t need to eat triple cream cheese, we have all the Kraft American slices you need right here!”. He also suggests that people are wowed by her because she is the opposite of the hottie Idols. I completely disagree with that assessment. This woman can interpret and deliver a tune in a very special way.
I hope this wonderful woman gets her chance to sing her song for many years to come. Perhaps her arrival on the international Idol scene will make people stop and think about all the older folks who have within them the power to move people through their music. Everyone deserves a chance to be heard- and you can’t judge a book by its cover.
So Sing, Susan, Sing!

